Quentin & Flora: A Roosevelt and a Vanderbilt in Love during the Great War : A Book Review


Quentin & Flora: A Roosevelt and Vanderbilt in Love during the Great War by Chip Bishop

Quentin & Flora: A Roosevelt and a Vanderbilt in Love during the Great War focuses on two years of a love story – but it is a wonderful love story, family story and coming-of-age story, all against the background of the Great War (as WWI was called at the time).

Quentin Roosevelt was the youngest of Theodore Roosevelt’s cubs, and arguably the most like him, with the most promise. He looked like TR, had his father’s happy faculty of turning a phrase, and embodied the old man’s broadness of interest, intelligence, leadership and plain guts. In essence, Quentin’s was a great loss of life cut short.

At four, Quentin was the youngest son of the youngest President, with the White House as his playground and the movers and shakers of the nation as his part-time playmates. He was great copy for the newspapers.  Author Chip Bishop delights the reader with Quentin stories, where one can see the seeds of leadership-in-situ. He would be a leader if his name were “Smith” and brought up in Hoboken. He was all-boy, with mischief in his soul, and brains in his head.

Flora Payne Whitney the girl who would love him is much fuzzier, albeit with a huge moneyed pedigree. Like all stories of poor-little-rich-girls, she lacked strong parental influence. Harry Payne Whitney, was a mega-industrialist, sportsman and generally absentee father. Her mother, Gertrude Vanderbilt Whitney was a personage in her own right: talented sculptress and generous patroness of the arts, focused on her artsy circles.

Hovering over the story, is the aura of an aging Theodore Roosevelt, who comes across at his finest: an engaged and affectionate father, which he truly was. Quentin’s mother, Edith, as was her nature, is the steady hand on the wheel, foot on the brake, known mainly for claiming that she raised her sons “to be eagles.”

Quentin also had  a gift all his own. Mechanics.  All things mechanical and in particular, aeronautics, dominated the teen-aged Quentin much like natural science dominated his father’s early years. It is refreshing that he had it all to himself. Billeted with a French family during the Great War, Quentin fixed their grandfather clock, which had not worked for thirty years – way before he was even born. Nice!

By the time the First World War began in Europe, the four Roosevelt sons, eager to prove their courage and eagleness, couldn’t wait to enlist – and this was years before the US committed itself as a participant. TR was filled with bully pride, having four sons in uniform. He would have gone himself, but a wiser Woodrow Wilson said no.

Also by the time still-teenaged Quentin enlisted in the French air force he had already met and fallen in love with pretty Flora Whitney. That they loved each other deeply and truly is apparent in their letters and in the memories of their friends. That TR was anxious to stir the romantic pot is also apparent. He tried to pull every string he could to get Flora to Paris, wedded and bedded, so the kids could at least have their “white hour” as the upright Theodore called it. Perhaps his was also a distant memory of his pretty and rich first wife who died young. In this case, TR’s efforts were in vain. Quentin’s great love affair was full of love, but remained unconsummated.

So here he was deployed overseas for his great adventure, flying little more than box-kites with motors, and Bishop’s story now belongs to the groom-to-not-be, with Flora assigned to the eternal role of woman-who-waits. To TR’s credit, he became a better father to Flora than her own. Meanwhile Quentin’s nearly eighteen months in Europe are somewhat marred by two incidents, perhaps roiled by historians who like nothing better than muddying waters. Author Bishop is not roiling; he is merely carefully reporting the murk.

The story goes that perhaps in deference to the age, wisdom and experience of his superior officers, nineteen-year-old Quentin, then stationed in Paris, declined a chance to go to the “front.” Some critics, including his brothers, considered him a embusque, or a “slacker.” This is muck-rakey. “Slacker” and “Roosevelt” cannot be used in the same sentence. Edith Roosevelt raised eagles, not chickens.

The second “controversy” concerns Quentin’s death: in the air, shot down in combat. Some say he was inexperienced (true), insufficiently trained (also true), rash, foolhardy and headstrong (probably true), but high in bravado and hot-dogging (no argument here). On the other side of the equation, is “twenty.” All those qualities apply to any twenty-year-old, including belief in their invincibility. Sum it up as (groan) Quent-essential.

Flora was devastated by the loss, and her fuzziness becomes even fuzzier in withdrawal. She doesn’t really become a “person” herself until well into middle age, when she parlays her modest artistic talents, large fortune and maternal legacy into management of the Whitney Museum of Art in New York. Married twice and mother of four, Flora will always have one foot in the art world, and the other in idle-rich. Her romance with Quentin may have become a distant memory in her long life, but more likely, may have become one of those intensely private memories never to be shared. One can only wonder what might have been…

Author Chip Bishop is a fine writer and he tells a good story. Actually it is a great story. In his hands, Quentin Roosevelt comes to life, boy-to-man, and even the fuzzy Flora is still winsome, warm and worthy of Quentin’s love and the Roosevelt family’s sincere affection.

It is an easy and engaging read.  You will enjoy it!

It would also make a great movie!


Quentin & Flora: A Roosevelt and a Vanderbilt in Love during the Great War

Chip Bishop

CreateSpace Independent Publishing Platform, April 2014



About Feather Schwartz Foster

Feather Schwartz Foster is an author-historian who has made more than 500 appearances discussing presidential history. She teaches adult education at the Christopher Wren Association (affiliated with William and; Mary College), and adult Education programs at Christopher Newport University. She has been a guest on the C-SPAN "First Ladies" program. She has written five books.
This entry was posted in Recommended Reading, Theodore Roosevelt and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

5 Responses to Quentin & Flora: A Roosevelt and a Vanderbilt in Love during the Great War : A Book Review

  1. awax1217 says:

    I was enchanted by teddy the bear and always admired his gun ho attitude. Not surprised by his off spring. Teddy died because he went to Panama to see the Panama canal building. It was to much for him.

  2. nerdtrips says:

    You have me intrigued. I may to read this book for myself.

  3. V.E.G. says:

    Whitney’s cousin was Meredith Baxter. Baxter’s mother was a Whitney and Meredith appeared in the highest rated sitcom in known history to be cancelled after one season, Bridget Loves Bernie!

  4. Susan Ozmore says:

    Definitely added to my to-read list. Thanks.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s