Frances Cleveland: The FLOTUS As Celebrity

When 49-year-old sitting president Grover Cleveland took a 21-year old bride, the country was enchanted.  

Frances Folsom: White House Bride

Adorabe Frances

Frances Folsom Cleveland was only twenty-one when she became First Lady.

New First Lady Frances Cleveland was not only young, but she was pretty.  She had a nice figure, a peaches-and-cream complexion – and dimples! The very antithesis of the grumpy looking and seriously overweight president.

At her very first reception, only a year out of Wells College, Frances delighted the crowds that came to greet her. She smiled easily, shook hands for hours on end (youth smiles on stamina), and had a kind word for all.

formal portrait

President Grover Cleveland

Within the month, she was the media darling. Letters poured with requests for her photograph. The White House ordered 10,000 photos to fill the demand. Within another few months, they had to re-order their supply.

The “Media” of the 1880s

After the Civil War, women began taking on an entirely new importance. Their activism during the Civil War had not only been impressive, it had been essential. They helped raise millions of dollars (North and South) for the war effort: planning dinners, fairs, dances, and bazaars . They organized hundreds of knitting and sewing circles. Most of all, they learned how to organize; how to spend their time effectively and efficiently; how to work together in committees – and some even learned how to speak in public.

To address this huge change in the public perception of women, magazines emerged  catering to those domestic issues: personal appearance, household management, child care, and even “suitable” hobbies. McCalls, Redbook, Ladies Home Journal and Good Housekeeping magazines made their initial appearances in the last decades of the nineteenth century – and are still around today. Supporting these magazines were thousands of advertisers of “womanly” and/or domestic products, from hand creams to the latest model sewing machine.

francesad4

First Lady Frances Cleveland was featured on covers of dozens of magazines.

Immediately after the Cleveland marriage, the magazines were pasting illustrations and sketches of Mrs. C. on their covers – with or without President Cleveland. They quickly found that their circulation boomed with every issue featuring the new young FLOTUS.

“Frankie” the Celebrity

Frances as an ad

Her image was used to endorse all sorts of patent medicines…

To promote mega-interest in their products, advertisers commandeered the likenesses (implying tacit endorsements) of well known persons without their knowledge or consent – let alone any monetary payment. There were no laws against it.

francesad2

…and undergarments…

Once the photographs of the new Mrs. Cleveland became available, they began appearing in magazines and newspapers, attached to advertisements for a broad variety of goods.

francesad3

…and even chewing tobacco.

She was seen in ads patronizing sewing machines, fabrics, a piano, and any number of pills and potions, implicitly suggesting that the First Lady was using, or endorsing said products. One of the products said to be used (daily, no less) was arsenic, claimed to be a beauty treatment for her complexion. Of course Mrs. Cleveland never did any such thing.

Mrs. C. and the Children

By the time of Cleveland’s second term (non-consecutive), First Lady Frances had become a mother. Ruth was born between the Cleveland presidencies. Esther was first Presidential baby to be born in the White House. (Frances was pregnant at the time of Cleveland’s second inaugural.) A couple of years later, their third daughter, Marion, made an appearance – but she was born in their summer home.   Their two sons were born after Cleveland’s term ended.

frandesad6

Illustrations were made depicting the entire Cleveland family tacitly “endorsing” department stores.

Now, as a young matron still in her late twenties, Frances was receiving letters soliciting advice on child care. Now the magazine covers were sketching idealized portraits of the Cleveland family unit: Mother, Father and children in a garden, or at the dinner table. Department stores ran “tacit” endorsements of Frances and the girls “window shopping” at their stores.

There were still no laws against the President, the First Lady, or even the First Children being “commandeered” in such a fashion – without their permission.

According to the New York Times, “The problem became so widespread that one of the president’s supporters introduced a bill in Congress to prohibit using the image of any real woman without her express written permission.  The bill’s failure left the Cleveland’s with no legal recourse, so they could only plead with businesses, usually to no avail, to cease and desist.”

The President grumbled and groused about the intrusions, but the advertisers paid no mind.  The Clevelands continued to have their likenesses used commercially.

The End of the Era

francesad5

President and Mrs. Cleveland had their photographs used to promote cigarettes.

Grover Cleveland’s second term was not successful. There were mounting issues, both domestic and international; some even pitted the conservative Democrat against members of his own party. Frances, of course, continued to be popular.

But once the second term ended, and the couple and their children “retired” to private life, the pervasive merchandising of their family dwindled. Cleveland, by that time, was sixty, and never considered “fashionable.” Mrs. C. was now occupied as wife and mother, and active in several community activities, such as the Kindergarten movement, and as a trustee for Wells College, her alma mater.

Cleveland’s health deteriorated, and he finally died at age 71. When Frances remarried a few years later (the first First Lady to do so), everyone wished her well, and for the most part, forgot about her.

Sources:

Boller, Paul Jr. – Presidential Anecdotes, Oxford University Press, 1981

C    Carpenter, Frank G. – Carp’s Washington – McGraw Hill, 1960

       Dunlap, Annette – Frank: (Frances Folsom Cleveland) – SUNY/Excelsior, 2009

            Foster, Feather – The First Ladies, Sourcebooks 2011

http://www.nytimes.com/learning/general/onthisday/harp/0612.html

 

Advertisements

About Feather Schwartz Foster

Feather Schwartz Foster is an author-historian who has made more than 500 appearances discussing presidential history. She teaches adult education at the Christopher Wren Association (affiliated with William and; Mary College), and adult Education programs at Christopher Newport University. She has been a guest on the C-SPAN "First Ladies" program. She has written five books.
This entry was posted in A POTUS-FLOTUS Blog and tagged , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to Frances Cleveland: The FLOTUS As Celebrity

  1. energywriter says:

    So interesting. This sounds like the Jackie Kennedy days. Any idea when law was passed protecting people’s likeness being used w/o permission.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s